Lost (the viewers, not the castaways)

Matt Zoller Seitz has an excellent site, which analyzes the various qualities and shortcomings of some of the great TV shows available today: The Wire, Battlestar Galactica, Deadwood and, of course, the enigmatic guilty pleasures of Lost. Read his analysis (and the comments) on the latter and it'll cover everything that's right and so-terribly-wrong with the show.